The following article was taken from the LVRJ.
Posted: May 10, 2012 | 2:00 a.m.
A Clark County judge disqualified District Attorney Steve Wolfson
from prosecuting a felony drunken driving case after finding “that a
true and extreme conflict of interest exists” between Wolfson and the
defendant, a former client.
Senior District Judge J. Charles Thompson issued the order, filed May 1, in the case against Edris Ghani.
The case is one of several in which defendants have sought to
disqualify the newly appointed district attorney based on his past work
as their lawyer. At least two other cases were delayed this week because
of pending motions to disqualify Wolfson.
Attorney Gabriel Grasso,
who now represents Ghani, said he knows of no other cases in which a
judge has ruled on the conflict issue involving Wolfson, a former
defense attorney and Las Vegas city councilman who was appointed to his
new position in late January.
Thompson ordered that a special prosecutor be appointed to prosecute
Ghani, a San Diego man accused of causing a fatal car crash near the
Strip in December 2010. Christina Konarski, 21, of Las Vegas was killed.
The judge made his ruling after conducting an evidentiary hearing.
Chief Deputy District Attorney Brian Rutledge said his office will
appeal Thompson’s decision to the Nevada Supreme Court, and the judge
agreed to stay his ruling pending the appeal.
According to the motion to disqualify the district attorney’s office
in the Ghani case, Wolfson personally represented the defendant between
December 2010 and July 2011, when Ghani replaced him.
“During this seven month period, Ghani relied on the attorney-client
privilege and shared confidential information with Wolfson,” according
to the motion.
In his opposition to the defense motion, Rutledge argued that Wolfson
“has sufficiently screened himself from any conflict related to
defendant’s case.”
The document also noted that Wolfson issued a memo in March to all
lawyers in the criminal division of the district attorney’s office
informing them that an “ethical shield” had been created regarding his
former clients.
“Furthermore, Mr. Wolfson made explicitly clear that any questions
regarding any potential conflicts were to be directed to Assistant
District Attorney Chris Owens, not Mr. Wolfson,” Rutledge wrote.
Owens supervises the 75 prosecutors who work in the criminal division.
“Finally, it should be noted that the Nevada Supreme Court has never
gone so far as to disqualify a prosecutor’s office where proper and
sufficient screening mechanisms were in place,” Rutledge wrote. “The
prosecutorial function in this case can be carried out impartially,
without the breach of any privileged communication, and the district
attorney’s office should not be disqualified as a whole.”
Wolfson is not the first defense lawyer to fill the role of district attorney in Clark County.
Stewart Bell, now a senior judge, also worked as a defense attorney
in private practice before becoming the county’s top prosecutor.
“The only distinction between the two of us is I planned for months
in advance that I was going to make the transition,” Bell said
Wednesday.
The Clark County Commission appointed Wolfson to serve out the
remaining 3½ years of David Roger’s unexpired term after Roger stepped
down.
On the other hand, Bell went through a primary and general election before voters chose him in 2004.
“I was divesting myself of cases, not taking on any new cases for months,” he said.
Bell does not recall ever facing a motion to disqualify the district
attorney’s office from a case based on his prior representation of the
defendant.
“I could see this coming and planned ahead,” he said. He admits he also was busy campaigning.
Bell served as district attorney from early 1995 through the end of
2002. He said the state has no “hard and fast rule” for determining when
a judge should disqualify a district attorney who previously
represented a defendant being prosecuted by his office.
“You have to look at these on a case-by-case basis,” he said.
Contact reporter Carri Geer Thevenot at cgeer@reviewjournal.com or 702-384-8710